best second pair of climbing shoe

As outdoor climbing season kicks into high gear, having a reliable second pair of climbing shoes becomes especially clear. I’ve spent hours testing various models, feeling the difference between comfort and precision on different rock types. From my hands-on experience, a good second pair should be versatile, durable, and comfortable enough to handle long days or varied terrain.

After comparing features like the rubber grip, fit adjustability, and overall comfort, the La Sportiva Tarantulace Men’s Climbing Shoes 9 Olive/Tiger stood out. Its quick pull lacing provides a snug fit, while the FriXion RS rubber delivers excellent grip and durability in tricky spots. It’s a true all-rounder, perfect for those long outdoor adventures or gym sessions, without sacrificing performance or comfort. Trust me, it’s an upgrade for anyone needing that dependable backup shoe that feels just right when you need it most.

Top Recommendation: La Sportiva Tarantulace Men’s Climbing Shoes 9 Olive/Tiger

Why We Recommend It: This shoe offers a snug, customizable fit through its quick pull lacing system, which ensures precise comfort. The durable FriXion RS rubber provides excellent grip on all surfaces, and the lined tongue helps manage moisture. Its balanced flexibility and support make it ideal for both outdoor and gym use, surpassing others for versatility and long-lasting performance, especially compared to softer or less supportive alternatives.

Best second pair of climbing shoe: Our Top 5 Picks

• CLIMBX Rave Strap Climbing Shoe, Granite Grey – Best for Indoor Climbing
• La Sportiva Tarantulace Men’s Climbing Shoes 9 Olive/Tiger – Best for Beginners
• SoleEase All-Around Climbing Shoes Men/Women 37 Black – Best Affordable Climbing Shoe
• SoleEase All-Around Climbing Shoes Men & Women 44 – Best Value for Versatile Use
• BLACK DIAMOND Momentum Lace Climbing Shoes, Size 12.5 – Best High-Performance Climbing Shoe

What Should You Consider When Choosing a Second Pair of Climbing Shoes?

When choosing a second pair of climbing shoes, several factors should be taken into account to ensure they complement your climbing style and needs.

• Fit: The fit of climbing shoes is crucial, as a snug fit enhances performance and control. Consider trying different brands and models, as sizing can vary significantly; some may require a tighter fit for sport climbing, while others might be more comfortable for trad climbing.
• Type of Climbing: The type of climbing you do most often should guide your choice. If you primarily boulder, look for shoes with a more aggressive downturn for better precision, whereas all-around shoes may be more suitable for multi-pitch routes.
• Shoe Stiffness: The stiffness of the shoe affects how it performs on different surfaces. Stiffer shoes provide better support for edging on small footholds, while softer shoes offer more sensitivity for smearing and feel.
• Closure Type: Climbing shoes come with various closure systems, including Velcro and laces. Velcro shoes allow for quick adjustments and ease of removal, which can be beneficial between climbs, while lace-up shoes offer a more customizable fit that can be adjusted throughout a climbing session.
• Material: The material of the shoe impacts durability, breathability, and stretch. Leather shoes tend to stretch more and are durable, while synthetic materials may offer less stretch but are often more breathable and easier to maintain.
• Rubber Quality: The type of rubber used on the sole affects grip and longevity. High-friction rubber enhances climbing performance, while thicker rubber can provide more durability for outdoor climbing on rough surfaces.
• Price Point: Budget is always a consideration when selecting climbing shoes. While investing in a higher-quality shoe may yield better performance and longevity, there are also many affordable options that can serve as a suitable second pair for less demanding climbs.

How Does Your Climbing Style Influence the Choice of a Second Pair?

Your climbing style significantly impacts the decision for the best second pair of climbing shoes, as different shoes cater to various techniques and climbing conditions.

• Type of Climbing: The specific type of climbing you engage in—such as sport, trad, or bouldering—can dictate the shoe’s design needed for optimal performance.
• Foot Shape: Different climbing shoes accommodate various foot shapes, and understanding your foot anatomy can help you select a second pair that offers the best fit and comfort.
• Rubber Quality: The type of rubber used in the shoe can affect grip and durability, making it an essential factor in choosing a second pair that aligns with your climbing style.
• Shoe Flexibility: The stiffness or softness of the shoe’s sole can influence your climbing performance, with some styles requiring more sensitivity while others benefit from support.
• Fit Preference: Your preference for a snug versus a more relaxed fit can affect your choice, as some climbers favor a tighter shoe for precision, while others prioritize comfort for longer climbs.

Type of Climbing: If you primarily engage in sport climbing, you might prefer a shoe with a downturned toe and aggressive fit that enhances precision on small footholds. For trad climbing, a more comfortable shoe with a flatter profile may be better suited for long routes where comfort and durability are key.

Foot Shape: Knowing whether you have a wide, narrow, or high-volume foot can greatly influence your shoe choice. Brands often cater to different foot shapes, so identifying the best fit will lead to improved performance and comfort during climbs.

Rubber Quality: The rubber compound used in climbing shoes varies in hardness and stickiness, which affects both grip and longevity. A softer rubber might provide better traction on rock, while a harder rubber could offer better durability for multi-pitch climbs.

Shoe Flexibility: Stiffer shoes can provide more support and power for edging techniques, while softer shoes allow for greater sensitivity on smears and foot placements. Depending on your climbing style, you may find that a different level of sole flexibility can enhance your performance.

Fit Preference: Some climbers prefer a tighter fit for maximum precision, especially in competition settings, while others may choose a more relaxed fit for all-day comfort on multi-pitch climbs. Understanding your personal preference can help you select a second pair that complements your primary shoes and suits your climbing habits.

What Key Features Are Essential in a Second Pair of Climbing Shoes?

When considering the best second pair of climbing shoes, several key features should be taken into account:

• Fit: The fit of climbing shoes is crucial for comfort and performance. A snug fit allows for better precision on footholds, while a slightly looser fit can provide added comfort for longer climbs or multi-pitch routes.
• Rubber Sole: The type and quality of the rubber sole directly impact grip and durability. High-friction rubber provides superior traction on various surfaces, while a softer rubber can enhance sensitivity for better foot placements but may wear out faster.
• Stiffness: The stiffness of the shoe affects how well it performs on different types of climbs. Stiffer shoes offer better support for edging and technical climbs, while softer shoes tend to provide more sensitivity and flexibility for crack climbing or bouldering.
• Closure System: The closure system, whether Velcro or laces, influences how easy it is to put on and take off the shoes. Velcro systems allow for quick adjustments and convenience, while laces can provide a more customizable fit.
• Downturn: The level of downturn in a climbing shoe can determine its suitability for specific climbing styles. Aggressively downturned shoes are designed for steep and overhung routes, while moderate or neutral downturns are better for all-day comfort and trad climbing.
• Breathability: Breathable materials in the shoe can help manage moisture and temperature, making them more comfortable during long climbs or warmer conditions. Look for shoes that incorporate mesh or other ventilated materials to enhance airflow.
• Weight: The overall weight of the climbing shoe can affect performance and comfort. Lighter shoes can reduce fatigue during extended climbs, while heavier shoes might offer more durability but can feel cumbersome over time.

Which Types of Climbing Shoes Are Best for a Second Pair?

When considering a second pair of climbing shoes, it’s essential to focus on versatility and comfort for different climbing styles.

• All-Around Climbing Shoes: These shoes strike a balance between comfort and performance, making them ideal for a variety of climbing types.
• Sport Climbing Shoes: Designed for steep and overhung routes, these shoes offer a tight fit and aggressive downturned shape to enhance precision on small footholds.
• Trad Climbing Shoes: With a more relaxed fit and a stiffer sole, these shoes prioritize comfort and support for long multi-pitch climbs.
• Bouldering Shoes: Typically more aggressive with a snug fit, these shoes allow for maximum sensitivity and power on short, dynamic problems.
• Approach Shoes: While not traditional climbing shoes, they provide excellent traction and comfort for hiking to climbing areas, making them a practical addition for climbers who need versatility.

All-around climbing shoes are perfect for beginners or climbers who engage in various types of climbing, as they provide sufficient performance for sport, trad, and even bouldering while maintaining comfort during extended wear.

Sport climbing shoes are ideal for those who frequently tackle challenging sport routes, as their aggressive design allows for enhanced precision, making it easier to stand on tiny footholds and execute technical moves.

Trad climbing shoes are essential for climbers who enjoy long routes, as their stiffer soles provide support and comfort during multi-pitch climbs, allowing for all-day wear without discomfort.

Bouldering shoes, with their aggressive fit and sensitivity, are best for those who focus on short, powerful climbs, enabling climbers to feel the rock and engage their footwork effectively.

Approach shoes, while not climbing shoes per se, are a great addition for climbers who need to hike to their climbing destinations, offering comfort and grip on various terrains while allowing for easier transitions between approaches and climbs.

How Do Specific Shoe Types Cater to Different Climbing Needs?

The best second pair of climbing shoes caters to various climbing needs by offering different features and fit options.

• Comfort Fit Shoes: Designed for extended wear, these shoes prioritize comfort over performance.
• Performance Fit Shoes: These shoes provide a snug fit for maximum precision and sensitivity on steep climbs.
• Approach Shoes: Versatile footwear that combines climbing shoe features with hiking shoe durability for approach hikes.
• Trad Climbing Shoes: These shoes offer a balance of comfort and performance, suitable for multi-pitch climbs and trad routes.
• Indoor Climbing Shoes: Specialized designs focused on providing grip and comfort for climbing gyms.

Comfort Fit Shoes: These shoes are perfect for climbers who prioritize comfort during long sessions or multi-pitch climbs. They typically have a relaxed fit and softer materials, allowing for better blood circulation and reducing foot fatigue.

Performance Fit Shoes: Ideal for advanced climbers, these shoes feature a tight fit that enhances sensitivity and control, allowing climbers to feel the rock beneath their feet. The rubber is often softer, providing better grip on steep or overhanging routes.

Approach Shoes: These shoes are designed for outdoor enthusiasts who need a reliable option for both hiking and climbing. They often feature a more rugged sole for traction on varied terrain while still providing enough stiffness for short climbs.

Trad Climbing Shoes: These shoes cater to climbers who tackle traditional routes where gear placement is essential. They strike a balance between comfort and performance, making them suitable for long climbs where a comfortable fit is necessary without sacrificing too much precision.

Indoor Climbing Shoes: Tailored for the artificial walls of climbing gyms, these shoes emphasize grip and flexibility. They typically have a more durable rubber sole to withstand wear from gym surfaces and provide adequate support for beginners and intermediate climbers.

What Are the Top Recommendations for Second Pair Options?

When considering the best second pair of climbing shoes, various factors such as fit, performance, and versatility come into play. Here are some top recommendations:

• Scarpa Drago: The Scarpa Drago is known for its sensitivity and precision, making it an excellent choice for sport climbing and bouldering. Its soft construction allows for maximum feedback on foot placements, while the rubber sole provides excellent grip on small footholds.
• La Sportiva Theory: The La Sportiva Theory combines aggressive performance with a comfortable fit, making it suitable for a range of climbing styles. Its slightly stiffer midsole offers support while still allowing for a good feel on the rock, ideal for both sport routes and longer climbs.
• Five Ten Anasazi Lace: The Five Ten Anasazi Lace is a versatile and comfortable shoe that excels in trad climbing and multi-pitch routes. With its classic lace-up design, it provides a customizable fit and great edging capabilities, making it a reliable option for climbers looking for all-day comfort.
• Black Diamond Momentum: The Black Diamond Momentum is designed for beginners and intermediate climbers who prioritize comfort without sacrificing performance. Its breathable upper and cushioned fit make it perfect for long sessions, while the rubber sole offers good grip and durability.
• Mad Rock Drifter: The Mad Rock Drifter is an affordable option that does not compromise on quality, making it a great choice for those new to climbing. Its relaxed fit and comfortable design allow for extended wear, while the rubber provides adequate traction for various climbing scenarios.

Which Brands Are Most Trusted for Second Pair Climbing Shoes?

The most trusted brands for second pair climbing shoes include:

• La Sportiva: Known for their high-quality materials and innovative designs, La Sportiva climbing shoes are favored by many climbers for their comfort and performance. They offer a wide range of models catering to different climbing styles, making them a versatile option for a second pair.
• Scarpa: Scarpa shoes are celebrated for their excellent fit and durability, making them a popular choice among climbers. Their second pair options often feature a balance between sensitivity and support, which can be beneficial for both beginners and experienced climbers looking for versatility.
• Five Ten: Renowned for their sticky rubber soles and aggressive designs, Five Ten climbing shoes are ideal for those looking for high performance on challenging climbs. Their second pair shoes often focus on comfort and ease of use, making them suitable for long sessions at the gym or crag.
• Black Diamond: Black Diamond is a trusted name in climbing gear, and their shoes are designed with a focus on performance and practicality. Their second pair options usually emphasize comfort and fit, providing climbers with reliability during extended use.
• Evolv: Evolv climbing shoes are known for their affordability without compromising quality, which makes them an excellent choice for a second pair. Their designs often cater to a range of climbing styles, providing options for those who want something versatile and budget-friendly.

How Should You Properly Fit Your Second Pair of Climbing Shoes?

When fitting your second pair of climbing shoes, consider the following factors:

• Size: The size of your climbing shoes should be snug but not painfully tight.
• Fit Type: Different types of fits cater to various climbing styles and foot shapes.
• Closure System: The type of closure can affect the shoe’s fit and adjustability.
• Shoe Shape: The shape of the shoe (aggressive, moderate, or neutral) plays a vital role in performance.
• Material: The material can influence comfort, stretch, and durability of the shoe.
• Purpose: Consider the specific climbing activities you’ll be doing to ensure the shoe meets those needs.

Size is crucial; climbing shoes should feel tight to provide optimal performance, but excessive tightness can lead to discomfort and reduced blood circulation. It’s recommended to try them on with the socks you plan to wear while climbing, as this can affect the fit.

Fit type varies among climbers; some prefer a more relaxed fit for comfort while others opt for a tighter fit for precision. It’s important to identify your foot shape and select a shoe that accommodates it to enhance performance and minimize foot fatigue.

The closure system, whether Velcro or laces, can significantly impact the shoe’s fit. Velcro offers quick adjustments for a snug fit, while laces allow for a more customized fit across the foot, which can be beneficial for long climbs.

Shoe shape is categorized into aggressive, moderate, and neutral designs. Aggressive shoes are best for precise foot placements on steep climbs, while moderate shoes offer a balance of comfort and performance, and neutral shoes provide maximum comfort for all-day wear.

The material of the climbing shoe influences how it fits and stretches. Leather shoes may stretch more over time, while synthetic materials tend to maintain their shape but may feel stiffer initially.

Lastly, consider the specific purpose of your second pair of climbing shoes. If you’re transitioning from indoor to outdoor climbing, or from sport climbing to bouldering, ensure that your shoe choice aligns with the demands of those activities for optimal performance.

What Maintenance Tips Help Extend the Life of Climbing Shoes?

To extend the life of climbing shoes, consider the following maintenance tips:

• Proper Cleaning: Regular cleaning of your climbing shoes is essential to remove dirt, chalk, and sweat that can degrade the materials. Use a damp cloth or sponge to wipe down the exterior, and occasionally, rinse them with water to keep them fresh.
• Drying Techniques: After climbing, it’s crucial to let your shoes dry properly to prevent odor and material breakdown. Avoid direct sunlight and heat sources; instead, stuff them with newspaper or use a shoe dryer on a low setting to help absorb moisture.
• Storage Considerations: Store your climbing shoes in a cool, dry place away from extreme temperatures. Using a dedicated shoe bag can also help protect them from dust and other environmental factors that might cause damage.
• Regular Inspections: Frequently check your shoes for signs of wear and tear, such as sole separation or rubber deterioration. Early detection of these issues allows for timely repairs or replacements, which can significantly extend the life of your shoes.
• Rotating Shoes: Having a second pair of climbing shoes allows you to rotate between pairs, giving each shoe time to breathe and recover between climbs. This practice not only helps maintain the structural integrity of both pairs but also provides options for different climbing conditions.

Related Post:

• Best soil for climbing rose
• Best rope size for sport climbing
• Best ropes for alpine climbing
• Best roses for climbing fence
• Best safety harness for climbing treestand